Moses at the Battle of Rephidim: “If I let my arms down, the other team will win!“
* * * *
This year’s Super Bowl has come and gone, which means that some of us still haven’t recovered. (The First Super Bowl is shown at right.) Which is another way of saying that – with the New England Patriots’ win over the Atlanta Falcons – the 2016-17 NFL season has come to an end.
That in turn means that among Patriot fans, there are some who think their team won because of something they did. The flip side is that among Falcon fans, there are some who are asking, “Why did my team lose? What did I do wrong?”
In my case, my sweetheart and I deliberately did not watch the first three quarters. And all during that time the Falcons did quite well, thank you very much. (We went to a movie, then went to dinner, though we did occasionally check the score.) First it was the Falcons leading 7-0, then leading 20-3, then 28-9. By that time we were home and decided to play cards.
Then Sweetheart decided to watch the fourth quarter, and things went downhill from there.
Despite my begging and pleading, she continued to watch the game. Finally I got up and left, first driving around the neighborhood, then walking around the neighborhood. And I kept waiting for the set of loud cheers – from all the Super Bowl parties around the neighborhood – that would signify the Falcons had finally pulled through; finally pulled it off.
It didn’t happen…
But the worst part was the way that “Sweetie” denied my urgent pleas for us to turn off the TV and go back to playing cards. For one thing, she said “I’m invested now.” (Which made about as much sense as saying she didn’t want to stop pounding herself over the head with a 2×4, for the reason that she was equally “invested.”) But the worst part was when she said, “You don’t seriously believe that us turning off the TV would change the outcome of the game, do you?”
Which brought to mind – eventually – what Moses did at the Battle of Rephidim.
I’ve written about that in posts like On football, Moses and Rephidim, and – from this blog – On the Bible and mysticism, and Conservative Christian – “Career buck private?” The gist of the episode in the Bible – at Exodus 17:8-16 – was that Moses “helped his team win:”
Moses, Aaron and Hur went to the top of the hill. As long as Moses held up his hands, the Israelites were winning, but whenever he lowered his hands, the Amalekites were winning. When Moses’ hands grew tired, they took a stone and put it under him and he sat on it. Aaron and Hur held his hands up – one on one side, one on the other – so that his hands remained steady till sunset. [E.A.]
So what do you suppose would have happened if Aaron and Hur refused to hold Moses’ hands up? Or what do you suppose would happen if the wife of Moses – or his Sweetheart for that matter – had come up the mountain and said, “Moses, you look ridiculous. Do you honestly think that holding your hands up like that is going to change the outcome of the battle?”
I’ll tell you what would have happened. Chaos: Israel defeated. No Moses, no Bible, no Jesus and His teachings to temper the inherent greed and cruelty of humans. Which of course would make some people happy. (As shown at right.)
Many such people think that life would be ever so much better without the Christian religion. They seem to think life today would be a matter of the sun perpetually shining down on a literal Paradise on Earth, complete with people of all nations and cultures frolicking happily around in a circle dance. Baloney!! (We saw plenty of “life without religion” in The Holocaust…)
Put another way: To such a claim I’ll give the same answer my Dad gave me after Watergate and Nixon’s resignation in 1974. I asked if it wouldn’t have been better if George McGovern had been elected instead of Nixon. His answer? “Things would have been worse, much worse!”
I don’t know if the country would have been better without the constitutional crisis of Watergate, but I do know history would be way different – way worse – without the tempering effect of real Christianity. Without the Men – and Women – in Black, keeping us on course:
I wear the black for the poor and the beaten down, Livin’ in the hopeless, hungry side of town… [F]or those who never read, Or listened to the words that Jesus said, About the road to happiness through love and charity, Why, you’d think He’s talking straight to you and me.
Hey, “Johnny Cash said it, I believe it, that settles it.”
But we seem to be ranging far afield here. The point of all this is that if Moses had listened to pure logic and reason – as opposed to instinct and intuition – the world would have been much worse off. If nothing else, with the Amalekites defeating the Children of Israel, world history would have been a much different, and “worse, much worse.” For one thing, Moses would never have gotten the chance to write – or at least finish – the first five books of the Bible, that “most influential, most published, most widely read book in the history of the world.”*
I figure that in all of this there is “some kind of object lesson…”
* * * *
* * * *
The upper image is courtesy of Rephidim – Wikipedia. The full caption: “Moses holding up his arms during the Battle of Rephidim, assisted by Hur and Aaron, in John Everett Millais‘ Victory O Lord! (1871).” As to previous posts on Moses at Rephidim, those posts noted that devoted sport-fans love to think if their team wins, they – the fans – helped out. (Through their rituals, “lucky shirts” and the like.) See for example Faulty logic: Post hoc, ergo propter hoc « Gotham Skeptic: “It’s a natural tendency for people to make connections between events. ‘When I do this, that happens…’ Primitive people [and perhaps modern football fans] developed superstitions in similar ways:”
Superstition is a large part of a fan’s repertoire these days, especially when the home team is in Super Bowl XLVIII today… Kenny Shisler has similar superstitions. The lifelong Broncos fan said he will wear Broncos gear all week long, but refuses to do so on game day… “Like the Bud Light commercials [say], ‘It’s only weird if it doesn’t work…’”
Incidentally, that “Gotham skeptic” article is from a site-reference “now defunct.” But see also Post Hoc Ergo Propter Hoc (Logical Fallacy … – Fallacy In Logic.
Re: The Bible as “most influential, the most published, the most widely read book in the history of the world,” see Asimov’s Guide to the Bible (Two Volumes in One), Avenel Books (1981), at page 7.
Asimov (1920-1992) was “an American author and professor of biochemistry at Boston University, best known for his works of science fiction and for his popular science books. Asimov was one of the most prolific writers of all time, having written or edited more than 500 books and an estimated 90,000 letters and postcards.” His list of books included those on “astronomy, mathematics, theBible, William Shakespeare’s writing, and chemistry.” He was a long-time member of Mensa, “albeit reluctantly; he described some members of that organization as ‘brain-proud and aggressive about their IQs.’” See Isaac Asimov – Wikipedia.
Also as to the Bible as most influential and most widely read, Asimov added:
No other book has been so studied and so analyzed and it is a tribute to the complexity of the Bible and the eagerness of its students that after thousands of years of study there are still endless books that can be written about it.
The “world without religion” image was courtesy of Date: July 4, 2016 Author: bige1972 … Commentsbigguycollege. (Another site-reference “now defunct.”) But see also Science without religion is lame. Religion … comquotefail.com: “Science without religion is lame. Religion without science is blind.”